R1: Select papers in academic literature

TODO: rerun searches and note individual search terms!!!!!!

Search criteria:

Databases

I will use Scopus and Web Of Science, as they sometimes differ significantly in the articles found.

Search terms general:

[About Transformative change] Transformative change synonyms

AND 

[nature synonyms](use dictionary suggested by Aidin)

AND 

(options/policy instruments)
("transformative change" OR "deliberate transformation*" OR "transformative turn*" OR "transition*” OR "social-ecological change*” OR "deep change” OR "fundamental alteration” OR "profound change” OR "profound transformation” OR "radical transformation” OR "transformational change” OR "complete change" OR "complete transformation” OR "drastic change” OR "in-depth transformation” OR "progressive change” OR "radical alteration” OR "radical change” OR "revolutionary change” OR "significant modification” OR "total transformation” OR "transformational shift” OR "radical shift”)

AND

("sustainab*" OR "environ*" OR "resilien*" OR "conserv*" OR "biodivers*" OR "ecosystem*” OR "nature*”)

AND 

("act*" OR "option*" OR "polic*" OR "policies” OR "measure*" OR "agenda*" OR "gov*" OR "right" OR "val*" OR "power" OR "business approach*” OR "legal instrument*” OR "regulatory instrument*” OR "regulat*” OR "enforcement*” OR "standard*” OR "governance framework*” OR "method*” OR "decision-making*” OR "plan*” OR "strateg*” OR "evaluation*” OR "assessment*” OR "programm*” OR "connect*” OR "offset*” OR "permit*” OR "ban*” OR "restrict*” OR "control*” OR "education system*” OR ”education” OR "awareness*” OR "learning*” OR "knowledge system*” OR "conservation approach*” OR "restoration approach*” OR "monitoring” OR "inventor*” OR "coordination*” OR "civic action*” OR "collective action*”or "political action*” OR "community action*” OR "capacity building*” OR "pathway*” OR "scenario*” OR "model*” OR "solution*” OR "innovation*” OR "incentive*” OR "subsid*” OR "tax*” OR "payment*” OR "debt*” OR "aid*” OR "fiscal transfer*” OR "investment*” OR "financ*” OR "product*” OR "market*” OR "account*” OR "register*” OR "funding*” OR "consump*” OR "chain*” OR "certification*” OR "participatory process*” OR "deliberate process*” OR "pluralism” OR "agreement*” OR "cooperation” OR "demand*” OR "policy context*” OR "scheme*” OR "protect*” OR "conserv*”or "cultural arrangement*” OR "practice*” OR "technique*” OR "infrastructure*” OR "access” OR "trade-off*” OR "NBSAP*” OR "legislative control” OR "legal restriction” OR "derivative trading” OR "commodity futures” OR "social responsibility” OR "marine areas” OR "multilateral agreements” or”transparency” OR "litigation” OR "labelling” OR "OEAM” OR "co-management” OR "co-production" OR "co-creation" OR "recognition" OR "system*" OR "access rights" OR "legislative arrangements" OR "treaties" OR "rules" OR "culturally specific" OR "place-based" OR " mechanism" OR "method" OR "index" OR "indicators" OR "approach*" OR "perspective*" OR "valu*")

Search results

Expected output: a list of papers that relate broadly to transformative change AND nature AND options

Web of Science - 332,188 hits

Scopus - 271,521 hits

Scopus search term

TITLE-ABS-KEY ( 
    ( "transformative change"  OR  "deliberate transformation*"  OR  "transformative turn*"  OR  "transition*"  OR  "social-ecological change*"  OR  "deep change"  OR  "fundamental alteration"  OR  "profound change"  OR  "profound transformation"  OR  "radical transformation"  OR  "transformational change"  OR  "complete change"  OR  "complete transformation"  OR  "drastic change"  OR  "in-depth transformation"  OR  "progressive change"  OR  "radical alteration"  OR  "radical change"  OR  "revolutionary change"  OR  "significant modification"  OR  "total transformation"  OR  "transformational shift"  OR  "radical shift" )  
    AND  
    ( "sustainab*"  OR  "environ*"  OR  "resilien*"  OR  "conserv*"  OR  "biodivers*"  OR  "ecosystem*"  OR  "nature*" )  
    AND  
    ( "act*"  OR  "option*"  OR  "polic*"  OR  "policies"  OR  "measure*"  OR  "agenda*"  OR  "gov*"  OR  "right"  OR  "val*"  OR  "power"  OR  "business approach*"  OR  "legal instrument*"  OR  "regulatory instrument*"  OR  "regulat*"  OR  "enforcement*"  OR  "standard*"  OR  "governance framework*"  OR  "method*"  OR  "decision-making*"  OR  "plan*"  OR  "strateg*"  OR  "evaluation*"  OR  "assessment*"  OR  "programm*"  OR  "connect*"  OR  "offset*"  OR  "permit*"  OR  "ban*"  OR  "restrict*"  OR  "control*"  OR  "education system*"  OR  "education"  OR  "awareness*"  OR  "learning*"  OR  "knowledge system*"  OR  "conservation approach*"  OR  "restoration approach*"  OR  "monitoring"  OR  "inventor*"  OR  "coordination*"  OR  "civic action*"  OR  "collective action*"  OR  "political action*"  OR  "community action*"  OR  "capacity building*"  OR  "pathway*"  OR  "scenario*"  OR  "model*"  OR  "solution*"  OR  "innovation*"  OR  "incentive*"  OR  "subsid*"  OR  "tax*"  OR  "payment*"  OR  "debt*"  OR  "aid*"  OR  "fiscal transfer*"  OR  "investment*"  OR  "financ*"  OR  "product*"  OR  "market*"  OR  "account*"  OR  "register*"  OR  "funding*"  OR  "consump*"  OR  "chain*"  OR  "certification*"  OR  "participatory process*"  OR  "deliberate process*"  OR  "pluralism"  OR  "agreement*"  OR  "cooperation"  OR  "demand*"  OR  "policy context*"  OR  "scheme*"  OR  "protect*"  OR  "conserv*"  OR  "cultural arrangement*"  OR  "practice*"  OR  "technique*"  OR  "infrastructure*"  OR  "access"  OR  "trade-off*"  OR  "NBSAP*"  OR  "legislative control"  OR  "legal restriction"  OR  "derivative trading"  OR  "commodity futures"  OR  "social responsibility"  OR  "marine areas"  OR  "multilateral agreements"  OR  "transparency"  OR  "litigation"  OR  "labelling"  OR  "OEAM"  OR  "co-management"  OR  "co-production"  OR  "co-creation"  OR  "recognition"  OR  "system*"  OR  "access rights"  OR  "legislative arrangements"  OR  "treaties"  OR  "rules"  OR  "culturally specific"  OR  "place-based"  OR  " mechanism"  OR  "method"  OR  "index"  OR  "indicators"  OR  "approach*"  OR  "perspective*"  OR  "valu*" ) 
)  
AND  
( LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE ,  "ar" )  OR  LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE ,  "re" ) )

R2: Screen for papers with concrete examples (e.g., case-studies, “implementation”, “example*”)

Search Criteria

Sub-sample of R1 corpus, search in abstracts, title, keywords

Additional search terms

The search will be re-run, adding the additional search terms as an AND condition.

("case stud*” or "case” or "study area*” or "example*” or "evaluation” or "solutions” or "implementation”or "concrete” or "empirical”, or "practical”)

Corpus A: academic articles with specific examples

Web of Science - 87,642 of previously 332,079 hits

Scopus - 85,624 of previously 271,521 hits

Search term

TITLE-ABS-KEY ( 
    (
        ( "transformative change"  OR  "deliberate transformation*"  OR  "transformative turn*"  OR  "transition*"  OR  "social-ecological change*"  OR  "deep change"  OR  "fundamental alteration"  OR  "profound change"  OR  "profound transformation"  OR  "radical transformation"  OR  "transformational change"  OR  "complete change"  OR  "complete transformation"  OR  "drastic change"  OR  "in-depth transformation"  OR  "progressive change"  OR  "radical alteration"  OR  "radical change"  OR  "revolutionary change"  OR  "significant modification"  OR  "total transformation"  OR  "transformational shift"  OR  "radical shift" )  
      AND  
       ( "sustainab*"  OR  "environ*"  OR  "resilien*"  OR  "conserv*"  OR  "biodivers*"  OR  "ecosystem*"  OR  "nature*" )  
      AND  
      ( "act*"  OR  "option*"  OR  "polic*"  OR  "policies"  OR  "measure*"  OR  "agenda*"  OR  "gov*"  OR  "right"  OR  "val*"  OR  "power"  OR  "business approach*"  OR  "legal instrument*"  OR  "regulatory instrument*"  OR  "regulat*"  OR  "enforcement*"  OR  "standard*"  OR  "governance framework*"  OR  "method*"  OR  "decision-making*"  OR  "plan*"  OR  "strateg*"  OR  "evaluation*"  OR  "assessment*"  OR  "programm*"  OR  "connect*"  OR  "offset*"  OR  "permit*"  OR  "ban*"  OR  "restrict*"  OR  "control*"  OR  "education system*"  OR  "education"  OR  "awareness*"  OR  "learning*"  OR  "knowledge system*"  OR  "conservation approach*"  OR  "restoration approach*"  OR  "monitoring"  OR  "inventor*"  OR  "coordination*"  OR  "civic action*"  OR  "collective action*"  OR  "political action*"  OR  "community action*"  OR  "capacity building*"  OR  "pathway*"  OR  "scenario*"  OR  "model*"  OR  "solution*"  OR  "innovation*"  OR  "incentive*"  OR  "subsid*"  OR  "tax*"  OR  "payment*"  OR  "debt*"  OR  "aid*"  OR  "fiscal transfer*"  OR  "investment*"  OR  "financ*"  OR  "product*"  OR  "market*"  OR  "account*"  OR  "register*"  OR  "funding*"  OR  "consump*"  OR  "chain*"  OR  "certification*"  OR  "participatory process*"  OR  "deliberate process*"  OR  "pluralism"  OR  "agreement*"  OR  "cooperation"  OR  "demand*"  OR  "policy context*"  OR  "scheme*"  OR  "protect*"  OR  "conserv*"  OR  "cultural arrangement*"  OR  "practice*"  OR  "technique*"  OR  "infrastructure*"  OR  "access"  OR  "trade-off*"  OR  "NBSAP*"  OR  "legislative control"  OR  "legal restriction"  OR  "derivative trading"  OR  "commodity futures"  OR  "social responsibility"  OR  "marine areas"  OR  "multilateral agreements"  OR  "transparency"  OR  "litigation"  OR  "labelling"  OR  "OEAM"  OR  "co-management"  OR  "co-production"  OR  "co-creation"  OR  "recognition"  OR  "system*"  OR  "access rights"  OR  "legislative arrangements"  OR  "treaties"  OR  "rules"  OR  "culturally specific"  OR  "place-based"  OR  " mechanism"  OR  "method"  OR  "index"  OR  "indicators"  OR  "approach*"  OR  "perspective*"  OR  "valu*" ) 
    )
    AND
    (
        ( "case stud*"  OR  "case"  OR  "study area*"  OR  "example*"  OR  "evaluation"  OR  "solutions"  OR  "implementation"  OR  "concrete"  OR  "empirical"  OR  "practical" ) 
    )

)  
AND  
( LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE ,  "ar" )  OR  LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE ,  "re" ) )

Corpus B: academic articles not in Corpus A

These do relate to transformative change, nature and options but do not provide information from a specific case (e.g., general recommendations, overviews).

The corpus is the corpus from R1 excluding the corpus from R2